Hollow-State Amps & Frequency Response

“Glass audio” has been growing in popularity among average audio enthusiasts for the past decade. Music-loving consumers worldwide enjoy the look and sound (i.e., the “warmth”) of tube amps, and innovative companies are creating demand by selling systems featuring tubes, iPod/MP3 hookups, and futuristic-looking enclosures. I suspect hybrid modern/retro designs will continue to gain popularity.

Many serious audiophiles enjoy incorporating glass tubes in their custom audio designs to create the sounds and audio system aesthetics to match their tastes. If you’re a DIYer of this sort, you’ll benefit from knowing how amps work and understanding topics such as frequency responses. In the April 2012 issue of audioXpress, columnist Richard Honeycutt details just that in his article titled “The Frequency Response of Hollow-State Amplifiers.”

Below is an excerpt from Honeycutt’s article. Click the link at the bottom of this post to read the entire article.

Early electronic devices were intended mainly for speech amplification and reproduction. By the 1930s, however, musical program material gained importance, and an extended frequency response became a commercial necessity. This emphasis grew until, in the 1950s and 1960s, the Harmon Kardon Citation audio amplifier claimed frequency response from 1 to 100,000 Hz flat within a decibel or better. Although today, other performance metrics have surpassed frequency response in advertising emphasis—in part because wide, flat frequency response is now easier to obtain with modern circuitry—frequency response remains a very important parameter …

Just which factors determine the low- and high-frequency limitations of vacuum tube amplifiers? In order to examine these factors, we need to discuss a bit of electric circuit theory. If a voltage source—AC or DC, it doesn’t matter—is connected to a resistance, the resulting current is given by Ohm’s Law: I = V/R. If the voltage source is of the AC variety, and the resistor is replaced by a capacitor or inductor, the current is given by: I = V/X where X is the reactance of the capacitor or inductor. Reactance limits current flow by means of temporary energy storage: capacitive reactance XC does so via the electric field, and inductive reactance XL stores energy in the magnetic field.

Figure 1 - The values of reactance provided by a 0.1-μF capacitor and a 254-mH inductor, for a frequency range of 10 to 30,000 Hz (Source: R. Honeycutt, AX April 2012)

Figure 1 shows the values of reactance provided by a 0.1 μF capacitor and a 254 mH inductor, for a frequency range of 10 to 30,000 Hz. Notice that capacitive reactance decreases with frequency; whereas, inductive reactance increases as frequency increases.

Click here to read the entire article.

audioXpress is an Elektor group publication.

 

 

audioXpress: HP456A Current Probe Restoration

Retro electronics (or “retronics”) projects are growing in popularity. Across the globe, professional engineers and DIYers alike are tweaking, updating, and hacking retro systems to create all sorts of innovative designs. Restoring and upgrading an old electronics tool, MCU-based design, or audio system can be a rewarding experience.

In the February 2012 issue of audioXpress magazine, Bill Reeve details how he restored a Hewlett-Packard 456A current probe (“Restoring the HP 456A Current Probe”). Here’s an abridged excerpt:

The restoration is finished and ready for cover installation (Soure: Bill Reeve AX 2/12)

The Hewlett-Packard 456A AC current probe is a treasure. It can be bought cheaply because many of the units sold were battery powered and all were designed with a now-out-of-date oscilloscope interface connector. However, when restored, the 456A is a fabulous addition to any test bench, matching the performance of more expensive modern instruments.

Released as a new product by the Hewlett-Packard Company in 1960, the 456A was HP’s first solid-state, stand-alone, clip-on current probe. Its elegantly designed amplifier uses two— then “state-of-the art”—PNP germanium transistors.

The Original Probe
In 1960, The Hewlett-Packard Journal (July-August, Vol. 11) proudly announced:

“This new probe measures current over the full range of the frequencies most commonly used in typical work—25~ to 20 megacycles—and over an amplitude range from below 0.5 mA to 1 A rms…The probe operates with an accompanying small amplifier…to convert the AC current being measured to a proportional voltage. This voltage can then be measured with a suitable oscilloscope or voltmeter. The current-to-voltage conversion factor is 1 mV/mA.”

The 456A operating and service manual is available at www.hparchive.com, but this scanned copy contains incorrectly annotated schematic values for R7 (should be 3300 Ω), R8 (should be 2700 Ω) and C5 (should be 0.01 μF).

Old battery-powered 456As are usually in excellent physical shape because when their batteries ran down these instruments were often shelved and forgotten. Another 456A advantage is that its probe head is wired directly to the amplifier, so they cannot be separated by surplus electronics dealers.

Restoration
Restoration of the 456A consists of three steps: replacing the old battery pack with DC power, restoring the amplifier electronics, and converting the obsolete oscilloscope banana plug interface to a BNC connector.

Step 1: Replace the old battery pack. Remove the two Phillips-head screws on the housing back to slide off the 456A’s cover. Re-thread the screws into the frame to keep them from getting lost. ….

Step 2: Restore the amplifier electronics. At this point, if you are happy with your current probe’s performance, you can skip the following upgrades, but these are five modifications you might need to perform to get your 456A working or improve its performance:

• Replace the electrolytic capacitors
• Replace the two germanium transistors
• Replace the 8-V breakdown diode (CR1)
• AC-couple the output
• Flow solder onto the printed circuit traces

Photo 6 is an annotated close-up of the amplifier’s single-sided printed circuit board. Following vacuum tube circuit convention, the +5 V is labeled “B+” and the –8 V is labeled “B–”. There are three electrolytic capacitors in the amplifier (see the horizontal silver cylinders in Photo 6), and their replacement is straightforward. ….

Photo 6: The amplifier's original printed circuit board (Source: Bill Reeve AX 2/12)

Step 3: Convert the oscilloscope interface to a BNC connector. This final modification can be performed one of three ways. Pomona electronics (visit the website pomonaelectronics.com) sells a female banana to male BNC adapter (Model 1296). You can cut the banana plug connector off the existing cable and attach a male BNC connector. This requires special tools.

You can replace the output cable with coax having one BNC end. This is a straightforward replacement. Photo 9 shows the new BNC output cable. …

Photo 9: BNC ouput cable installed (Source: Bill Reeve AX 2/12)

This restoration should make your 456A ready for another 50 years of service.

Note: The complete article appears in the February 2012 issue of audioXpress magazine. audioXpress magazine, like Circuit Cellar, is an Elektor group publication.